Bank Deducted TDS on Your Loan Settlement Waiver? Claim It Back

Section 194R Exemption Rules and Tax Refund Rectification

12 min readCBDT Circular 18/2022 & Sec 154Updated: Nov 2026

1. The Form 26AS Shock: Erroneous TDS on Loan Waivers

Few things shock a borrower more than finding tax deducted on a settled loan. You finish your One-Time Settlement (OTS). You pay the agreed sum. Months later, you check your Form 26AS or Annual Information Statement (AIS). There sits a deduction under Section 194R.

Consider a typical case. You owed twenty lakh rupees. The bank agreed to settle for ten lakh rupees. The bank wrote off the remaining ten lakh rupees. But the branch accountant made an error. They treated the ten lakh waiver as a business perquisite. They deducted ten percent TDS. They deposited one lakh rupees with your PAN.

This creates a huge issue. The computers at CPC Bengaluru see this deduction. They treat Section 194R as business income. They expect you to show ten lakh rupees as income in your tax return. If you do not, they issue notices under Section 139(9) or Section 143(1)(a). They demand tax at slab rates up to thirty percent, plus interest and penalties.

Warning: Automated Tax Demands

Do not ignore a Section 194R entry in Form 26AS. If you file without resolving this mismatch, CPC will add the full waiver amount to your income. They will issue a heavy tax demand and block your refunds.

2. Statutory Grounding: Section 194R & Circular 18/2022

Section 194R came into effect on July 1, 2022. It mandates a ten percent tax deduction on benefits or perquisites from a business or profession. It applies when the value exceeds twenty thousand rupees in a year.

Banks feared this new rule. When a bank settles a bad debt, it already takes a loss. If the bank had to pay ten percent TDS on the waiver, it would suffer a double loss. To solve this problem, the CBDT issued Circular No. 18/2022 on September 13, 2022. Question 1 gave a clear, binding answer:

Statutory Exemption: CBDT Circular No. 18/2022 (Question 1)

One-time loan settlements or loan waivers granted by Public Financial Institutions, Scheduled Banks, Cooperative Banks, State Financial Corporations, and NBFCs are NOT subject to TDS under Section 194R.

CBDT circulars bind all income tax officers under Section 119. A bank that deducts TDS on a loan waiver violates this binding rule.

3. Supreme Court Precedent: Mahindra & Mahindra Ratio

Tax officers sometimes argue that even if the bank made an error, the waiver is still taxable income for you. This claim is incorrect. The Supreme Court settled this issue in CIT v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. (2018) 404 ITR 1.

The Supreme Court examined two provisions of the Income Tax Act:

Rule 1: Section 28(iv) Covers Only In-Kind Benefits

Section 28(iv) taxes benefits received in kind, not in money. A loan is a cash transaction. A loan waiver discharges a cash liability. It is not an in-kind perk. Thus, Section 28(iv) cannot apply.

Rule 2: Section 41(1) Protects Capital Accounts

Section 41(1) taxes debts when you claimed them as expenses in earlier years. A loan on capital account is not a business expense. Waiving it is a capital receipt, not taxable income.

This applies to all settlements. If you used our step-by-step loan settlement process to close an uncollateralized loan, the waiver is a non-taxable capital receipt.

4. Personal Debt vs Business Perquisites: Section 28(iv)

Section 194R requires a link to a business or profession. Many borrowers are salaried employees, retirees, or home makers. They take loans for medical costs, education, or family needs. These loans have no business connection.

A retail loan settlement is an agreement under Section 63 of the Indian Contract Act 1872. It is not business profit. Applying Section 194R to personal debt has no basis in law.

Note on Business Overdrafts

If you settled a business overdraft where you claimed unpaid interest as an expense, that interest portion may face tax under Section 41(1). But the principal waiver remains non-taxable, and Section 194R TDS remains prohibited.

5. Twin Recovery Pathways: Bank vs IT Portal

You have two ways to fix this error. You can ask the bank to correct its TDS return, or you can claim a refund when you file your income tax return.

ParameterBank TRACES RouteITR Refund Route
Action NeededRevised Form 26Q under Sec 200(3)Schedule EI & Sec 154 Form
Who FilesBank Accounts TeamTaxpayer on e-Filing Portal
Best Used IfBank took cash from youTax deposited under your PAN
Average Time15 to 30 days30 to 60 days (with interest)

If you paid any settlement amount in cash, make sure you followed cash payment rules under Section 269ST so you do not invite extra penalties.

6. Bank Correction: Form 26Q Rectification on TRACES

Under Section 200(3) of the Income Tax Act and Rule 31A, deductors can file correction statements. They do this on the TRACES portal. The bank can file a correction statement to delete the erroneous entry.

Take these steps to make the bank fix the mistake:

  1. Collect your Form 26AS, your settlement letter, and payment receipts.
  2. Write to the Branch Manager and Nodal Officer. Cite Circular 18/2022 Question 1.
  3. Ask them to file a Form 26Q correction on TRACES to delete the entry under your PAN.
  4. If the bank took cash from you for TDS, demand that they credit it back to your account within 15 days.
Sample Notice Text to Bank

Under Question 1 of CBDT Circular No. 18/2022 dated 13.09.2022, loan settlements by banks are exempt from Section 194R. Your deduction on Loan [Number] is unlawful. Please file a Form 26Q correction on TRACES within 15 days to delete this entry from PAN [PAN], or I will complain to the RBI Ombudsman.

7. Tax Return Protocol: Reporting in Schedule EI

If the bank does not file a correction before you submit your return, claim the tax credit yourself in your ITR. Follow these three steps:

Step 1: Claim Full TDS in Schedule TDS-2

Claim the full TDS amount under Schedule TDS. Make sure the deductor TAN and amount match your Form 26AS.

Step 2: Enter Waiver in Schedule EI

Do not add the waiver to your taxable income. Go to Schedule EI and select Any Other Exempt Income. Enter the waiver figure. Add a note: Capital receipt from loan settlement exempt under Supreme Court ruling in CIT v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd.

Step 3: Keep Complete Records

Save your OTS letter and bank receipts. If you had property loans, ensure you finished securing original property title deeds after settlement to hold full proof that the loan is closed.

8. Defeating Section 143(1)(a) CPC Mismatch Notices

The automated system at CPC Bengaluru may flag this return. It sees TDS under Section 194R with no matching business income. It sends a notice under Section 143(1)(a) proposing to add the waiver to your income.

You have 30 days to reply online. Never accept this adjustment. Follow these steps:

  1. Log in to the tax portal and go to Pending Actions > e-Proceedings.
  2. Click Submit Response for the Section 143(1)(a) notice.
  3. Select Disagree with Addition.
  4. Choose Income is exempt or not liable to tax as your reason.
  5. Cite CBDT Circular 18/2022 and CIT v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. in your text.
  6. Upload your OTS letter, bank ledger, and a copy of Circular 18/2022 as PDFs.

9. Portal Walkthrough: Section 154 Rectification

If CPC processes your return and disallows your TDS credit, file a rectification request under Section 154. You can file this within four years from the end of the financial year.

Online Rectification Steps
  • Go to Services > Rectification on the e-filing portal.
  • Click New Request and pick the right Assessment Year.
  • Select Tax Credit Mismatch Correction.
  • Check your Form 26AS details and make sure the bank entry is included.
  • If income was reclassified, pick Return Data Correction.
  • Submit with an Aadhaar OTP or EVC.

The CPC usually processes these requests within thirty to sixty days. It will correct your tax calculation and issue your refund.

10. Section 244A Interest: 6% Annual Statutory Return

When the government delays your refund, the law gives you interest. Under Section 244A of the Income Tax Act, you receive simple interest on your refund.

Interest Rate under Section 244A

The interest rate is 0.5% per month, or 6% per year. If you filed your return on time, interest runs from April 1 of the assessment year until the day the refund hits your bank account.

For example, if one lakh rupees was wrongfully deducted and your refund takes eighteen months, the department must pay nine thousand rupees in interest. Under Article 265 of the Constitution of India, the state cannot keep tax collected without legal authority.

11. Escalation Matrix: RBI Ombudsman & CPGRAMS

If the bank refuses to correct its TDS return or refund your cash, take formal steps right away:

Tier 1: Bank Principal Nodal Officer (PNO)

Send a formal written complaint to the Nodal Officer. State that the branch breached CBDT Circular 18/2022. Give thirty days to fix it.

Tier 2: RBI Integrated Ombudsman (cms.rbi.org.in)

After thirty days, file a case under Clause 10 of the RBI Integrated Ombudsman Scheme 2021. The Ombudsman can order the bank to fix TRACES records and grant up to twenty lakh rupees for mental harassment.

Tier 3: CPGRAMS Portal (pgportal.gov.in)

File a grievance on CPGRAMS against the bank or on e-Nivaran to your Assessing Officer to demand departmental action.

Resolving Distressed Unsecured Debt Through Strategic OTS

Do not let tax confusion stop you from clearing heavy debt. If you struggle with overdue loans, read our guide on personal loan debt settlement to get lawful 30% to 50% waivers and full financial freedom.

12. Frequently Asked Questions

Did my bank have any legal authority to deduct TDS on my loan settlement waiver?▼

No. The CBDT issued Circular No. 18/2022 on September 13, 2022. Under Question 1, it clarifies that loan settlements and waivers by banks and NBFCs are exempt from TDS under Section 194R.

Why did my bank branch deduct 10% TDS despite the clear CBDT exemption?▼

Branch accountants often misunderstand tax rules. In many cases, automated core banking tools tag all loan write-offs as business benefits. In other cases, banks deduct tax from collateral sale proceeds by mistake.

Is a personal loan or credit card settlement waiver taxable as income?▼

No. The Supreme Court in CIT v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. held that waiving a capital debt is a non-taxable capital receipt. Personal loans are not business debts. They cannot be taxed under Section 28(iv) or Section 41(1).

How can I force the bank to delete the erroneous Section 194R entry from Form 26AS?▼

Serve a formal demand notice on the Branch Manager and Nodal Officer citing Circular 18/2022. Demand that the bank file a revised Form 26Q correction on TRACES under Section 200(3) to remove the entry from your PAN.

What should I do if CPC Bengaluru issues a Section 143(1)(a) mismatch notice?▼

Log in to the tax portal and submit your response under e-Proceedings. Disagree with the addition. Explain that the waiver is an exempt capital receipt under Supreme Court precedent, and attach your OTS letter.

How do I claim a refund of TDS through an online Section 154 rectification?▼

Go to Services and select Rectification on the e-filing portal. Choose Tax Credit Mismatch, enter your Form 26AS details, and submit. The CPC will process the request and credit your refund.

Can I claim interest on the delayed TDS refund from the Income Tax Department?▼

Yes. Under Section 244A, you get simple interest at 0.5% per month (6% per year). The department calculates this from April 1 of the assessment year until the date they pay the refund.

What remedy do I have if the bank refused to return cash deducted as TDS?▼

If the bank took cash from you or kept money from your surplus, file a complaint with the RBI Banking Ombudsman under Clause 10. The Ombudsman can order a full refund plus compensation.

Official Statutory Resources & Regulatory Portals

RBI & GOVT VERIFIED

Access official government portals, regulatory ombudsman channels, and statutory dispute resolution bodies governing Indian banking and borrower rights:

View All 85 Guides →
Debt Traps & FraudRBI Fair Practices Code

How to Spot a Fake Loan Settlement Letter: 7-Point Verification Checklist

Rogue recovery agents frequently generate fake settlement sanction letters on fabricated letterheads, collect payments via personal UPI accounts, and disappear. Review the 7 mandatory authenticity checkpoints, including official domain email verification and the golden rule of depositing only into your loan account.

6 min readRead Manual→
Debt Traps & FraudSection 63 Contract Act & RBI OTS

How to Write a Loan Settlement Request Letter to Your Bank

Submitting a formal One-Time Settlement request letter is the first official step to resolving bad debt in India. Learn how to prove genuine financial inability, choose realistic 35% to 50% waiver offers, use court-tested English and Hindi formats, and obtain an official bank sanction letter.

9 min readRead Manual→
Debt Traps & FraudSections 269T & 269ST IT Act

Cash Payment in Loan Settlement: Section 269ST IT Penalty Warning

Paying cash to settle bank loans triggers a 100 percent income tax penalty under Section 269T (repayments over 20,000) and Section 269ST (receipts over 2 Lakh). Discover why rogue recovery agents demand cash and how to protect yourself using safe banking channels.

8 min readRead Manual→

Community Discussion & Case Notes

0 Comments

No comments posted yet. Be the first to share your experience below!

Join the Discussion & Share Your Experience

Have you dealt with this situation or received a notice? Share your questions or experience with other borrowers.

0/500

Find this content helpful?

If this guide has helped you navigate your settlement journey, consider showing some support to keep this platform running.